Commit of katolaz's issue 2 submission, as received.

This commit is contained in:
Solderpunk 2021-07-11 11:27:07 +00:00
parent 4ec32dcff5
commit ea1fdb2413
1 changed files with 96 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@ -0,0 +1,96 @@
On the intriguing beauty of whistled languages
==============================================
I have always found intriguing how humans have found literally thousands
of different systems to communicate their thoughts. We call those
systems "languages", and when we talk about them we probably think to
the fact that each language uses a different word to denote the same
object or concept. But there is one aspect that (almost!) all the
languages on Earth have in common: they are "spoken", which means that
they consists of combinations of sounds made by modulating the flow of
air through the mouth, and by movements of our tongue and lips. This is
how we get vowels and consonants: leave your mouth wide open and you get
an "a", stretch your lips in a smile and you get an "e", blow into your
closed mouth for half a second and then release the air by suddenly
opening your lips, and you get a "p". And so on.
But "speaking" is not the only possible manifestation of a human
language. The strangest kind of languages I have bumped into are the
so-called "whistled languages" [1], which are exactly what they say:
languages consisting of combinations of tones that are whistled by the
"speaker". You might be surprised to discover that there are literally
hundreds of known whistled languages. One example is "Silbo Gomero" [2]
(literally, "Gomeran whistle"), a whistled language used by the
inhabitants of La Gomera in the Canary Islands. Most of the people in La
Gomera can still speak the language today, thanks to a program to
revitalise its usage, but all of the inhabitants understand it.
Linguists believe that whistled languages are connected to the necessity
to communicate over long distances and across impervious terrains, and
in fact La Gomera is known for its deep valleys and canyons. And this
same pattern seems to be shared by most of the whistled languages still
in use today, from Asia to central America: the terrain of a region
forced its inhabitants to whistle their thoughts, in order to be heard
more easily and more efficiently.
Some recent studies have even shown that the speakers of "whistled"
languages actually process whistles using the same regions of the brain
that other humans use to process words in the usual "spoken" languages.
But why am I telling you about "whistled" languages? Well, because I
recently started learning an artificial language that resembles a lot
"whistled" languages. I am talking about Morse code [3]. Yes, the one
used back in the days for telegraphy, where each letter of the alphabet
consists of a short series of dot and dashes, or dits and dahs, and so
on. It turns out Morse code is far from extinct, as it is currently in
use by radio amateurs around the globe to communicate in the so-called
"Continuous Wave" mode, normally abbreviated "CW" [4]. Basically, you
send your message as a concatenation of long and short tones or pulses,
which are then decoded by the person at the other end of the contact.
If you ever try to learn Morse code (it is totally doable in a few
weeks, or even less) you will be told that you must not think of each
letter as consisting of a certain sequence of dots and dashes, but
rather as a "sound", a new way to "pronounce" and "perceive" the same
letter you are used to read and write [5]. The aim is to force your
brain to think of "A" whenever you hear the sound "di-daa" and to think
of "R" whenever you hear the sound "di-daah-dit", without having to
double-translate the sound to dot-and-dashes and then back to the images
of letters that our brain constructs and keeps.
And how much is this different from teaching your brain that a certain
whistle, with a certain tone, must be associated with "A", while another
whistle, with another tone, shall be associated to "R"?
I really think learning CW is indeed not too different from learning a
whistled language. You forget quite soon of dots and dashes, and only
hear "the sound of T", and then start putting together individual sounds
into words, to recognise "the sound of 'THE'". Obviously, this process
requires a certain amount of time and effort, but it is not much
different from learning any other language. The words are still in
English, or Spanish, but they are articulated in a totally different
way.
Coincidentally, CW (i.e., Morse code over radio) is often one of the few
transmission modes that can successfully "get through" long distances or
bad propagation conditions, when all the other voice modes cannot.
Exactly as the whistling patterns of Silbo Gomero get through the
valleys of La Gomera, while most of your shouting would not be
intelligible at all. Obviously, there are several more efficient
transmission modes available nowadays, mostly digital ones, which do not
require much human intervention, if any at all. But I like to think that
the deep reason why Morse code is still in wide use in ham radio is that
hams like to "whistle" their thoughts, and find pleasure in putting some
concrete effort to "copy" the whistled thoughts of their correspondents.
Like the Gomerean have been doing for hundreds of years.
KatolaZ
-+-+-+-
References:
[1] gopher://gopherpedia.com/0/Whistled language
[2] gopher://gopherpedia.com/0/Silbo Gomero
[3] gopher://gopherpedia.com/0/Morse code
[4] gopher://gopherpedia.com/0/Continuous wave
[5] http://www.tasrt.ca/bookdown.html